What's better than stumbling upon a hidden gem? Let us help the serendipity along and point you to a couple of our favorite tucked-away bistros.
Past the shop-lined streets of Old Town and the looming silhouette of the Carson Mansion, the window-lined Humboldt Bay Bistro is building a devoted following. Some of that may be owing to the pleasure of eating somewhere out of the way, a restaurant that feels like your own secret. Some of the appeal of this sweet house on the water is the view. But mostly it's the fine execution of beloved French-American dishes that has locals returning for celebrations and weeknight dinners alike.
The escargot is a tender and faithful iteration of the classic, with garlic, herb compound butter, wine and shallots. (Don't be shy — ask for extra bread to dredge in the sauce and your gently smiling server will deliver it without judgment.) Follow it up with the Caesar salad, made tableside from a genuinely pretty spread of ingredients. You'd do well to order the pan-seared duck, too. The blush-pink slices arrive with a Bing cherry Port wine reduction that is intense and not overly sweet. Be prepared to defend your plate from the swipes of your companions.
1436 Second St., Eureka
(707) 443-7339
www.humboldtbaybistro.com
Wednesday - Monday | 5 - 9 pm
Once that cocktail has warmed you up, move to the surf-and-turf take on nachos, a pile of house-made chips piled with peppery smoked pork (brined and smoked over four days) and blue crab guacamole. The game hen, served with a dollop of garlic mashed potatoes, takes a Southern route, too, brined with brown sugar and deep fried whole to yield tender, sweet meat and savory, crinkled skin.
The generous Jambalaya pasta — spinach fettuccine with Andouille sausage, shrimp, crawfish and Tasso ham — has all the kick and body of the original rice dish in its sauce. You may need to split the vertiginous Bistro Salad, a wedge of iceberg (would glacier be more fitting?) under an avalanche of shrimp, blue crab, bacon and tomatoes, with a mustard-flecked dressing. Only pace yourself so you don't miss the pecan pie topped with bananas Foster.
773 Redwood Drive, Garberville
(707) 923-7007
www.garbervillebistro.com
Tuesday - Saturday | 5 - 9 pm